AUS: McGuigan Simeon defends suspension – report

Most popular

Interview - Zico Coconut Water founder

Sustainability to shape post-pandemic recovery

Could coronavirus make for more caring companies?

The just-drinks Analyst returns

Interview - William Grant senior category director


The outgoing head of McGuigan Simeon has defended the decision to cancel contracts with wine grape growers as being an "indictment of the Australian wine industry."

Speaking to The Australian this weekend, Brian McGuigan, who is set to retire next month, claimed that the company was on firm legal ground when it decided late last week to keep suspensions in place for 16 grape varieties. The wine company, which has been in conflict with grapegrowers' associations in New South Wales and Victoria after suspending contracts, said on Wednesday (8 February) that it would lift suspensions on only nine grape varieties.

Several grape growers have threatened legal action against McGuigan Simeon, but McGuigan told the paper: "I'm very confident any action against us would not be successful."

The decision to suspend existing contracts was "a bit of an indictment of the industry itself, that we ended up with more grapes than we could sell as wine," McGuigan said in the interview.

"There were laws that encouraged a lot of people to come into the grape-growing business," he said. "People thought there was a never-ending thirst for Australian wine in the international market ... and everybody had a feeling we should continue to plant grapes, because we would never have enough."

"I know we seem to be conspicuous because we've been open about it and taken action some would say is aggressive, but I think we had no option," McGuigan added. "We must make sure, from our shareholders' point of view, that we're not the meat in the sandwich."

He said many wine contracts "don't heed changes in the marketplace ... and can't react to market pressure".

He advocated a joint partnership approach to the crisis "whereby we share the gain, but also share the pain".

"If things are tough, it should be tough for everybody," McGuigan told The Australian.

Earlier this month, McGuigan confirmed that he would be replaced as managing director at the company by Dane Hudson. The change will take place on 1 March.

Sectors: Wine

Related Content

"In the US, we don't sell a litre. Come on, have a go!" - Interview, Australian Vintage CEO Neil McG...

"I've never seen anything before that has affected us as much as Brexit" - Interview, Australian Vin...

Australia puts brakes on Kirin's Lion Dairy & Drinks sale to Mengniu Dairy - report

Australia puts brakes on Kirin's Lion Dairy & Drinks sale to Mengniu Dairy - report...

Coca-Cola Co defends claims of quashing scientific research

Coca-Cola Co defends claims of quashing scientific research...

Oops! This article is copy protected.

Why can’t I copy the text on this page?

The ability to copy articles is specially reserved for people who are part of a group membership.

How do I become a group member?

To find out how you and your team can copy and share articles and save money as part of a group membership call Sean Clinton on
+44 (0)1527 573 736 or complete this form..

Forgot your password?