US: Coca-Cola Co brands orange juice lawsuit 'meritless'

By | 5 March 2013

Coca-Colas Simply Orange is included in the lawsuit

Coca-Cola's Simply Orange is included in the lawsuit

The Coca-Cola Co has hit back at a lawsuit over the marketing of its orange juice brands after a US judge allowed the case to reach court.

The company claimed yesterday (4 March) that the plaintiffs will be unable to prove allegations that it misleads customers over the purity of its juice ingredients in Simply Orange, Minute Maid Premium and Minute Maid Pure Squeezed. It also warned that Friday's decision by a district court in Kansas City is not a final judgement. 

"This ruling is not a decision on the merits, but merely allows the plaintiff the opportunity to try to prove the allegations in their complaint,” Coca-Cola told just-drinks. “This they cannot do.”

The combined complaint was first lodged in August and includes plaintiffs from across the US. According to court documents, all allege that Coca-Cola falsely claims its brands Simply Orange, Minute Maid Premium and Minute Maid Pure Squeezed are “100% pure-squeezed, natural orange juice”, while they are actually “heavily processed, pasteurised, de-aerated and flavoured”.

In Friday's ruling, Judge Fernando Gaitan Jr said the allegations are sufficient to overcome Coca-Cola's counter-arguments, Bloomberg reported.

Yesterday, Coca-Cola defended its Minute Maid and Simply Orange brands, saying they are labelled in accordance with regulations. “This is a meritless case against which we will continue to vigorously defend ourselves,” the company said.

Last year, Coca-Cola was banned in the UK from using the word "nutritious" to describe its Vitaminwater brand after complaints it was misleading given that the drink contains 23g of sugar.

Expert analysis

The Future of the US Non-Alcoholic Drinks Packaging to 2017

The Future of the US Non-Alcoholic Drinks Packaging to 2017 is a data only report providing extensive and highly detailed time series consumption data on primary and outer packaging in the market

Sectors: Legislation, Soft drinks

Companies: Coca-Cola Co

There are currently no comments on this article

Be the first to comment on this article

Related research

Coca-Cola Co, The in Soft Drinks (USA)

The company is looking to solidify its position as the top US soft drinks manufacturer by broadening its portfolio of non-carbonates offerings through deals like purchasing VitaminWater maker Glacéau in 2007, acquiring a minority stake in coconut wat...

The Coca-Cola Co in Health and Wellness (World)

The Coca-Cola Co (TCCC) is the leading player in both soft drinks and in HW soft drinks. The company’s strength is based on its diversity of category presence from HW carbonates to RTD tea and bottled water. This allows the company to benefit from va...

Coca-Cola Co, The in Soft Drinks (World)

The Coca-Cola Company slightly underperformed the world’s soft drinks market amid the recession in Western Europe and slow economic recovery in the US. It is actively expanding in low calorie carbonates to retain consumers and widening the use of nat...

Related articles

just the Round-Up - The week in drinks

The top ten stories published on just-drinks this week:

US: Coca-Cola speaks out over Olympics gay protest

The Coca-Cola Co has responded to a protest by gay rights campaigners in the US over its sponsorship of the Russian Winter Olympics, arguing that the company "celebrates diversity".

Round-Up - NPD: Will Summer Diet Soft Drink Swoon Jump Start CSD Innovation?

Struggling sales for diet soft drinks should see a new wave of innovation break over the category. Tom Vierhile reports.

just-drinks tagline

Not a member? Join here

Decrease font sizeDecrease font sizeDecrease font size Increase font sizeIncrease font sizeIncrease font size Comment on this article Email this to a friend Print this page