Blog: It's the dock for the French paradox
Chris Brook-Carter | 30 June 2004
French paradox or not, doctors and winemakers are on a collision course in France, as the wine industry attempts to halt a decline in sales by telling consumers to drink more. It is a dangerous plan from the winemakers in a political climate dominated by health concerns over excess alcohol consumption.
The French Parliament is to vote in coming weeks on a Senate amendment that would allow an increase in advertising on billboards, radio, in magazines and other mainstream media.
However, the proposal has angered doctors groups. "What this amounts to is that we can't export all the wine we want to, so French people will have to drink it," said Alain Rigaud, president of the National Association for the Prevention of Alcoholism and Addiction.
However, this issue is far from black or white. It is hard to imagine that wine advertising will turn France into a nation of alcoholics, and the wine industry argues that strong growth in beer and spirit sales shows that the real beneficiaries of falling wine consumption have been drinks multinationals, and not the anti-alcohol lobby.
"If you're not out there on the market, somebody else will just take your place with other products that can damage health," said one of the lawmakers.
At present the law allows advertisements to contain only factual information about a product, including its name, manufacturer, alcohol content and origin. This means any generic campaign for an AOC, like Burgundy or Bordeaux, falls foul of the law because they don't refer to a single product.
The small size of many winemakers in France means they cannot afford to advertise on their own. The argument goes that this law, as it stands, currently favours large internationals and discriminates against France’s own producers. The Senate amendment would permit a broader array of messages, slogans and images.
But France’s health lobby says France is drinking quite enough wine already – the average French person over the age of 14 drinks a quarter-bottle of wine a day. Rigaud said: "Advertising would just legitimise problem drinkers in their problem drinking."
Yesterday was long. Very, very long. What started with an alarm in London at 0530 GMT ended with a Bacardi eight-year-old nightcap in Puerto Rico at 0730 GMT the following morning....
This weekend, Bacardi is hosting a three-day music event on the private island of Palomino just off the coast of Puerto Rico....
Warmest thanks to all of you who filled in our annual readers' survey this month. The results are very important for us to learn from and look to improve our service to you....
Today's news that German spirits firm Mast-Jägermeister has joined UK responsible drinking organisation The Portman Group may raise eyebrows in some quarters....
- Scotch's Slipping Crown: Convenient for Diageo?
- Comment - Has Scotch Whisky Jumped the Shark?
- Can Beer Learn from Keurig and Nespresso?
- just The Preview - Anheuser-Busch InBev's Q3 & YTD
- C&C Group 'puzzled' by Spirit Pub Co rejection
- Diageo partner Beckham turned down Beck's deal
- Whisky downturn slows Diageo's Scotch spend
- Mast-Jägermeister targets UK off-trade boost
- EXCLUSIVE - Mast-Jaegermeister, TWE join watchdog
- Beam Suntory to roll out "Scotch-infused" Bourbon
- Global Cognac insights - market forecasts, product innovation and consumer trends research
- Global Scotch whisky insights - market forecasts, product innovation and consumer trends research
- The IWSR Global Trends Report 2014
- Wine in the United Kingdom
- Spirit Market in China to 2018 - Market Size, Trends, and Forecasts