ARG: Quinsa investor slams board over AmBev sale
A minority investor in Argentinian brewer Quinsa has complained to the company over plans by controlling shareholder AmBev to buy back the company's remaining shares.
In an open letter to Quinsa's board, private equity firm Duma Capital Partners said yesterday (8 February) that it is not satisfied with the handling of AmBev's offer to outstanding shareholders.
AmBev, the Latin American subsidiary of global brewer InBev, owns around 97% of the company's voting rights and around 91% of the economic interest in Quinsa.
Late last month, InBev was given the green light from the Commission de Surveillance du Secteur Financier in Luxembourg to purchase all of the remaining Class A shares and Class B shares in the Argentine brewery. The offer includes Class B shares held as American Depositary Shares (ADS).The purchase price would be US$3.35 per Class A share and $33.53 per Class B share (US$67.07 per ADS).
"We expected the (Quinsa) board to follow established procedures and fair process to maximise value for shareholders," Duma Capital Partners wrote in the letter.
"Such a process would include forming an independent committee, conducting an independent valuation of Quinsa, and negotiating a fair price.
"We were therefore surprised when the board decided to recommend the offer only three business days after the tender announcement, seemingly without deliberation. In our opinion, Quinsa is worth significantly more than $67.07 per ADS."
Duma Capital Partners has accused the board of disregarding its fiduciary duty to the remaining public shareholders. It added: "The process that led to the board's declaration of the fairness of this offer is incomplete and conflicted. The process needs to be more than just rubber-stamping a lowball bid from a controlling shareholder."
Upon contacting Quinsa, Duma Capital Partners was referred to AmBev. "It is not AmBev's responsibility to ensure that this offer represents maximum value for shareholders," the letter continues. "In fact, AmBev shareholders are probably quite happy with AmBev's attempt to secure 100% ownership of Quinsa at such a low price.
"It is your responsibility as members of the Quinsa board and fiduciaries to ensure that this offer maximises value for Quinsa's public shareholders."
The company has called for Quinsa's 2006 results to be made public "so that shareholders have the same information as AmBev and the board when deciding whether or not to accept AmBev's offer".
"As it stands," Duma Capital Partners concluded, "we do not intend to tender our shares and we do not believe this tender will succeed."
When contacted by just-drinks today, InBev said: "We have an official offer document in the market which was prepared in accordance with the appropriate regulations. The offer ends on 28 February and, until that time, it would be inappropriate to comment on individual shareholder views and opinions."
The Boston Beer Company is to buy a brewery from Diageo in the US....
Quilmes Industrial has revealed a small drop in the number of shares in the company....
InBev has dismissed claims by the federation of Belgian drinks retailers that its pricing policy is unfair and distorts competition in the sector....
Quilmes Industrial (Quinsa), the Luxembourg-based subsidiary of South American drinks combine AmBev, has said the filing of its 20-F form for 2006 will be delayed....
The Famous Grouse and Maxxium UK have both signed up Woo Communications as their global marketing communications agency....
InBev has confirmed reports that it is to release its Lowenbrau beer brand in the Indian market....
A local broker has lowered its coverage of Mexican brewer Grupo Modelo....
InBev and SABMiller have had their share coverage raised....
- Analysis - SABMiller to add bolt-ons in Africa?
- A-B InBev's Move on Tennent's Super Makes Sense
- India: Everyone's Favourite Spirits Market
- Brand Diversification Driving Craft Brewery Growth
- Analysis - Stock Spirits: Poland's number one
- Diageo scraps Arthur's Day, but singer left sad
- Pernod Ricard's Café de Paris Pear, Pomegranate
- PepsiCo CEO sees "profound" change in US consumers
- William Grant sinks GBP185,000 into "No" camp
- SodaStream silent on John Lewis pullout in UK