US: Monster Beverage claims 'no evidence' in death lawsuit

By | 5 March 2013

Monster has defended itself against the lawsuit

Monster has defended itself against the lawsuit

Monster Beverage has claimed there is no medical evidence to support allegations that its energy drinks contributed to the death of a 14 year-old girl.

The company was hit with a lawsuit in Maryland, US, last October by the family of the girl, Anais Fournier. The lawsuit alleged that Ms Fournier had drunk two cans of 24oz Monster drinks before her death, causing caffeine toxicity. 

But, in a lengthy riposte yesterday (4 March), the California-based company denied the claim. Daniel Callahan, a lawyer acting for Monster, said there is “no medical, scientific or factual evidence to support the Maryland medical examiner's report of 'caffeine toxicity’”. The company based its assertion on findings from a group of physicians and a coroner it had asked to examine the medical records of Ms Fournier. 

Earlier this month, the company announced it is changing the classification of its energy drinks to 'conventional foods' and will list caffeine content on products.

Callahan added: "The Maryland medical examiner concluded that Ms Fournier died of natural causes and an independent pathologist hired by the State of Maryland concluded her cause of death to be cardiac fibrosis, which is a thickening or scarring of the cardiac tissue.” 

Kevin Goldberg, a Maryland lawyer for Ms. Fournier’s family, told the New York Times that the lack of a caffeine test “doesn’t tell us anything” and that the family was looking forward to a jury deciding Monster’s accountability. 

The energy drinks category has been under scrutiny of late. The US Food & Drug Administration revealed last year it was investigating energy drinks that had been cited in reports of a number of deaths. Two US senators are also probing the category over health concerns.

Last week, Monster reported a slowing in its full-year profits growth, but sales remained healthy.

Expert analysis

Functional Foods and Drinks

This report analyzes the worldwide markets for Functional Foods and Drinks in US$ Million by the following Product Segments: Cereals and Grains, Beverages, Dairy Products, Snacks, and Other Functional Foods.

Sectors: Soft drinks

There are currently no comments on this article

Be the first to comment on this article

just-drinks tagline

Not a member? Join here

Decrease font sizeDecrease font sizeDecrease font size Increase font sizeIncrease font sizeIncrease font size Comment on this article Email this to a friend Print this page