UK: Greene King faces down pensioners in pub row
UK brewer Greene King has demanded four local pensioners contribute to its legal costs after they failed to block an extension to the opening hours of a local Greene King pub.
The brewer and pub group operator is seeking up to GBP29,000 (US$55,000) in legal costs from the residents after fighting off opposition to open the Dog and Partridge, in Bury St Edmunds, Suffolk, until 1am.
The row is notable as the UK's Licensing Act, introduced last year, sought to calm fears that late-night opening would lead to increased binge drinking by giving local residents the right to appeal against an extension to opening hours.
However, the pensioners lost an appeal to the local council and to the local magistrates' court, although the latter ruled they would not have to pay costs. Greene King, which in the year to 30 April made profits of GBP119.6m, plans to take the residents to the UK High Court to recover its legal costs.
Sarah Clover, a lawyer for the two elderly couples, said: "Some of the costs bandied around the magistrates courts can be quite astronomical. It's simply not feasible to ask residents to take on the risk."
She told the Daily Mail newspaper: "But if they don't pursue their rights, then a big part of the empowerment the Licensing Act was supposed to give them is rendered null and void."
A spokesman for the UK's Department for Culture Media and Sport refused to comment on the case as it is "a matter for the courts". However, he told just-drinks today (20 November) that any residents with "reasonable grounds for appeal" should not be penalised.
He added: "The magistrates' association and the justices' clerks society have advised that awarding costs for a licensing appeal should be an exception and not a rule."
Greene King said it had listened to the concerns of local residents during its bid to extend the pub's opening hours but insisted that the pensioners knew there could be "cost implications" if they lost their appeal.
The company said its move to recoup its legal costs was not a direct challenge to the pensioners. "We are not challenging the four people who brought the appeal but the magistrate's decision not to award costs," the company said.
"We want to establish the principle that people should have to contribute to the costs of cases being heard a second time round. Otherwise, if all objectors could appeal without ever having to pay any costs, there is a real threat to the thousands of community pubs across the country. We will not be looking to recover more than the appellants can easily afford to pay."
Greene King has launched an updated version of its flagship ale in the UK....
UK regional brewer Greene King has launched what it claims to be the first bottled English speciality beer....
UK regional brewer and pub group Greene King has posted increased sales and volumes for the 36 weeks to 7 January, a performance in line with expectations....
UK regional brewer and pub group Greene King said today (5 December) that trading was in line with expectations after posting a strong set of first-half figures....
UK brewer Greene King has sold 155 pubs based mainly in the south of England to Admiral Taverns Holdings....
Advisors for UK regional brewer Greene King have confirmed that the company is looking to sell around 150 tenanted pubs in southern England....
UK regional brewer Greene King has refused to be drawn on reports that it is looking to sell around 150 tenanted pubs in southern England....
Greene King IPA has been named as the official beer of England's Rugby Football Union (RFU) in a multi-million pound deal lasting four years....
- Comment - Heineken's 'No' Cuts SABMiller Options
- Irish whiskey eyes a slice of Scotch's global pie
- Scottish Independence and Scotch Whisky
- SABMiller spurned by Heineken: The start of the en
- Can the New World Learn a Lesson from the Old?
- Patron Spirits' Patron Citrónge Lime
- Heineken rejects SABMiller purchase proposal
- Wm Grant CMO to head Orangina Scweppes Int'l
- Diageo's Special Releases 2014
- SABMiller, Heineken silent on takeover offer talk