Comment - The Danone Wahaha legacy
Danone's trademark dispute with Wahaha may have ended, but the fallout from the one of the most long-running and high-profile disputes between joint venture partners in the drinks sector will not disappear so easily.
Danone and Wahaha said today (30 September) that they have agreed to end their dispute, after Danone agreed to ditch its 51% stake in the two companies' Chinese joint venture.
With allegations of copycat production and lengthy, not to mention costly, legal battles, it is a tale that contains some of the worst nightmares for western companies seeking partners in emerging markets.
There is already evidence that the Wahaha dispute has influenced Danone's strategy in these markets.
The French food and soft drinks giant announced in April that it would pursue growth in India, another key emerging market, on its own. The firm said it was pulling out of a turbulent 13-year joint venture with India's Wadia Group and would seek to grow its business "autonomously" in the country.
Having had its fingers singed, Danone appears sceptical about working with 'local' partners in emerging markets.
From the Wahaha side, it is clear the company believes the dispute with Danone could jeopardise the confidence of foreign investors in China.
China's Government took part in the peace talks between the two companies and its obsession with presenting a friendly face to outside investors is stamped all over today's official Wahaha statement.
"China is an open country. Chinese people are broad-minded people. Chinese companies are willing to cooperate and grow with the world's leading peers on the basis of equality and reciprocal benefit," chimed Wahaha Group chairman Zong Qinhou.
The statement is reminiscent of China's strenuous efforts to deny claims of "economic nationalism" after officials blocked Coca-Cola Co's takeover of Huiyuan Juice Group.
In the end, companies are not going to turn their backs on so-called 'emerging markets' - the clue, of course, is in the name.
Danone today reiterated its "longstanding commitment" to China. Shortly before Coca-Cola Co was bounced out of the Huiyuan deal, it announced a three-year US$2bn investment plan for China, which is now the soft drinks giant's third largest market in the world by volume.
Multinational drinks companies cannot afford to be absent from the likes of India, China, Russia and Brazil, because of the growth opportunities those countries hold.
But, the Wahaha example will not be lost on those who operate in such markets and it may lead some to rethink their approach.
The Coca-Cola Co this week began construction of a bottling plant in Malaysia in the first step of a MYR1bn (US$285m) investment in the country over the next five years....
Reports earlier today (18 March) have suggested that The Coca-Cola Co has tabled a bid to purchase a stake in Russian juice producer Nidan Juice. ...
The Coca-Cola Co this month began construction of a bottling plant in Malaysia as part of its plan to invest MYR1bn (US$285m) in the country over the next five years....
- American whiskey does a vodka - Analysis
- Battle continues for Pernod Ricard in US and China
- Pernod Ricard's FY Performance by Region, Brand
- Concha y Toro's H1 performance - Focus
- Why consumers don't care about vodka's provenance
- Diageo strengthens Charmer Sunbelt distribution
- Heineken integrates cider and beer
- Pernod Ricard "in line" after full-year results
- Corby's FY suffers from US focus
- New whisky distillery set for Edinburgh
- Future growth opportunities for global spirits
- Global gin insights - market data, product innovation and consumer trends research
- Pernod Ricard SA - Mergers & Acquisitions (M&A), Partnerships & Alliances and Investment Report
- Global rum insights - market forecasts, product innovation and consumer trends research
- Global vodka insights - market forecasts, product innovation and consumer trends research