COMMENT: Diageo uproots Scotch whisky ops
There are circumstances when tradition and heritage are to be cherished and there are others when both can hang like dead weights around your neck.
The difficulty is deciding when to cut loose, and, when you do, convincing other people that you are right.
That is one of the conundrums facing Diageo this week as it breaks cover with plans to close a packaging plant in Kilmarnock, and so breaking a tie, albeit slightly strained, with the town that gave birth to Johnnie Walker Scotch whisky in the early 19th Century.
Diageo also plans to close the Port Dundas distillery next year, pulling down the shutters on 200 years of distilling at the facility.
Diageo is not the first and most certainly will not be the last to make such moves.
Earlier this year, Heineken signalled that it would close and sell off the Beamish & Crawford brewery in the Irish city of Cork. The brewery was founded in 1792, but the site has been used for brewing since at least the mid-17th Century, historians estimate.
Then, last year, Carlsberg closed its historic brewery in Valby, Denmark. And, around four years ago, again in the UK, Scottish & Newcastle moved the brewing of Newcastle Brown Ale out of Newcastle.
It is often suggested that such policies are driven by the accounting departments of major firms, with little consideration for the product and knock-on consequences.
Certainly, there are sound reasons why breaking historical links can damage a brand. Marketing departments must privately despair at times, looking on as a good heritage "story" on a major brand is sucked into an apparent black hole of mass, banal production.
On an emotional level, most people also have a natural streak of conservatism that pricks the nerve endings when faced with a break from the past; a break from familiarity.
Then, and not least importantly, comes the potential economic impact on an area: the near certainty of job losses and all of the socio-economic baggage that comes with them.
However, sometimes it is necessary to make tough changes.
Diageo is still very clearly committed to Scotch whisky - as well as expanding the Cameronbridge grain distillery near Fife, the group still plans to open its new distillery at Roseisle on Speyside. It has invested around GBP100m in both, and remains the number one Scotch whisky maker.
Diageo has long-term strategy documents on how it believes the global Scotch market is likely to play out, just-drinks understands from sources familiar with the company.
The group's 4,500 workforce will be reduced to somewhere nearer 4,100 if its restructuring plan goes ahead as proposed.
It is up to the group to convince the wider world that it has made the right call.
With the end of the year looming, just-drinks is running a series of 'Top Tens of the Year' in the run-up to Christmas. Today, it's the Top Ten Most Read News Stories of 2009....
Like the other sectors of our industry, the economy cast a shadow over the spirits category in 2009. The aftershocks of the downturn spread around the world, with Scotland appearing to be the epicentr...
With the end of the year looming, just-drinks is running a series of 'Top Tens of the Year' in the run-up to Christmas. Today, it's the Top Ten Most Read Interviews of 2009....
As the decade draws to a close and just-drinks reflects on its first ten years of publication, our editorial team picks the ten stories that defined the noughties for the drinks industry and shaped ou...
A French court ruling to recognise the case of creditors due a total of EUR375m (US$535m) from struggling drinks group Belvédère will not damage the firm's relaunch plan, its lawyer has told just-drin...
A fire broke out at St James' Gate brewery in Dublin, home to Diageo's Guinness brand, yesterday (21 December)....
Chivas Brothers has launched a print advertising campaign for its Royal Salute brand. The campaign will be launched in January 2010, initially in China and will then be rolled out through the Asian re...
Sales of fine wine at auction house Christie's during 2009 were broadly level with 2008, as Asia helped to maintain demand during the global economic downturn....
- Ten questions for Diageo - Analysis
- Have spirits companies forgotten the mainstream?
- How craft beer has shattered its US shackles
- Does alcohol accelerate the onset of dementia?
- Ashwagandha - The next functional drinks trend?
- Moet Hennessy unaffected by LVMH Dior buy
- BrewDog moves into spirits with LoneWolf launch
- Portman Group heads to Tesco for new chief exec
- William Grant names Europe & NA Travel Retail head
- Johnnie Walker Bourbon Cask & Rye Finish - NPD
- Global Scotch insights - market forecasts, product innovation and consumer trends
- Global Champagne and sparkling wine insights - market forecasts, product innovation and consumer trends
- Battle of the Generations - The fight for iGen, Millennial, Gen X and Baby Boomer consumers
- Craft Beer: Coming of Age or Past Its Prime?
- Myanmar - ISA Country Report