Comment - Has The Coca-Cola Co Jumped From Frying Pan to Fire?
Coca-Cola has endured pressures over high sugar content
Two years ago, when serious speculation emerged over a plan by Coca-Cola Co to buy Monster Beverage Corporation, the energy drinks maker had only recently changed its name from Hansen Natural Corp.
The company was still in the early stages of a transition to a pure-play energy drinks firm that should culminate at the turn of the year when, under the terms of a US$2.15bn deal announced yesterday, it hands its non-energy brands to Coca-Cola along with a 16.7% stake. However, despite its relatively short history, Monster was that year already involved in a fist of lawsuits and regulatory battles that have plagued it ever since.
Indeed, in September 2012, an analyst wrote that legal pressure on the energy drinks market because of health and wellness concerns in the US may have dissuaded Coca-Cola from a move on Monster.
So have those concerns lessened, leading to yesterday's swoop from Coca-Cola? Analysts I spoke to today intimated that fears over Monster's troubles may have been overstated in the media, and from a business viewpoint, the gains from a partnership with Monster, and its potential in the global market, outweigh domestic regulatory wrangling.
However, there are other issues at play.
During the release of Monster's first-half results last week, CEO Rodney Sacks said the company was now focussing efforts on products that are “more drinkable... lighter in calories and lighter in taste”. Products such as the no-calorie Zero Ultra and its soon-to-be-launched extension Ultra Sunrise.
Ultra Zero has been very successful for Monster, so it's no surprise the company is keen to replicate it. But the product also addresses consumer fears over sugar that Sacks said are beginning to creep into the energy drinks category.
This, of course, is something Coca-Cola knows all about. It has had to deal with a declining CSD category in the US because of consumer concerns over sugar intake. Even diet sodas have seen volumes drop in the country as consumers turn away from artificial sweeteners such as the sucrlose and acesulfame potassium that are used to sweeten Zero Ultra.
So is Coca-Cola, which is joining up with Monster to expand away from its core CSD business, merely jumping from the frying pan into the fire?
If anything, energy drinks contain more sugar than CSDs - according to the website Caffeineinformer.com a 16-ounce can of Monster's namesake product contains 3.38 grams-per-ounce while Coca-Cola's has 3.25.
This could be one of the reasons why Coca-Cola is only taking a minority share in Monster. Nomura analysts pointed out today that past Coca-Cola conquests that have involved a 100% stake, such as the Vitaminwater takeover in 2007, have “not always been successful”.
The reduced stake lessens the health and wellness risks Coca-Cola is exposed to while at the same time allowing it to put the full weight of its global distribution network behind Monster's fast-growing brands.
It's a sweet deal for both companies. Now they must hope that sugar doesn't turn it sour.
Companies: The Coca-Cola Company
The company is looking to enhance its core capabilities of consumer marketing, commercial leadership, franchise leadership, and bottling and distribution operations to drive its sales growth and profi...
Coca-Cola face a challenging situation in which economic recovery is fragile in developed markets, while China and Brazil are seeing a slowdown in sales. Consumers’ desire for diverse and healthy beve...
Worries about the health and safety of sports and energy drinks continued to grow in 2013. Off-trade value sales of sports and energy drinks grew by 4% in 2013 after growing by 9% in 2012. Off-trade v...
The Coca-Cola Co has said smaller pack sizes are driving "a tremendous amount of positive growth" in the US as it looks to drive performance through improving price/mix....
- The category today - Scotch Whisky I
- Today's Market Trends - Scotch Whisky II
- Key Brands Performance - Scotch Whisky IV
- Tomorrow's Market Trends - Scotch Whisky III
- Category Trends - Scotch Whisky V
- Beam Suntory names CFO, makes structural changes
- Diageo to accept US$1m South Korea fine
- Analysts clash over AB InBev SAB Brexit impact
- Brown-Forman shuffles director pack
- Pernod switches Travel Retail Europe op's director
- Global Scotch whisky insights - market forecasts, product innovation and consumer trends
- Global RTD insights - market forecasts, product innovation and consumer trends
- Soft Drinks Global Overview: Growth Opportunities Between Category Lines
- Consumer and Market Insights: Wine Market in China
- Global travel retail insights - market forecasts, product innovation and consumer trends