Chris Mercer

Comment - Constellation Brands reveals dire Hardy profits

By Chris Mercer | 10 January 2011

Hardys profits are dwarfed by Constellation Brands US wine business

Hardys profits are dwarfed by Constellation Brands' US wine business

Constellation Brands' rationale for selling its Australia and UK wine business has become clearer following the group's publication of third quarter profits.

Constellation Wines Australia and Europe reported operating profits of just US$2.5m for the first nine months of the wine company's fiscal year. That's a 78% drop on the same period of the previous year, even though profits at the BRL Hardy-dominated division actually rose by 21% in the third quarter.

The figures shed extra light on why Constellation has agreed to sell its Australian and UK wine operations for a sliver of their former value. Champ Private Equity will pick up the pieces for AUD290m (US$290m), when Hardys alone cost Constellation $1.85bn in 2003.

Just prior to that deal, in March 2003, BRL Hardy reported full-year net profits of AUD84m. What a catastrophe Constellation has ended up walking into. That said, how many of us would have spotted the cliff's edge without hindsight's cruel torch?

At the time, let's not forget, Australian wine - just like the national cricket team - was going great guns in export markets. French vignerons were waving their arms in Gallic despair at the New World revolution and several observers reckoned that Hardys undersold itself in the Constellation deal.

Today, Australia is awash with unwanted wine and unloved cricketers - homegrown varieties, at least.

While Constellation has taken a sizeable hit, the group believes it can rise from the proverbial ashes as a finely-tuned, profitable unit. Its North American wine business was 200 times larger than Hardys in terms of operating profits in the first nine months of its current fiscal year. Wine sales in North America were triple those in the Europe and Australia business over the period. More generally, the outlook for wine consumption in the US remains brighter than in, say, the UK.

Hardys, in other words, has been effectively dropped as dead weight. There is still a lot of work ahead for the Robert Mondavi owner, however. Its operating profits from wine in North America slipped by 7% in the nine-month reporting period, to $507m, and sales only crept up by 1% in value. Investors duly gave the group a kicking on the stock market.

Wine is a tough place to be right now. Constellation still has to prove that it can persuade consumers to part with more cash in the wine aisles or find a way to get bottles into drinkers' hands more profitably. Neither will be easy, particularly as the recession hangover continues to linger.

Sectors: Company results, Wine

Companies: Constellation

View next/previous articles

Currently reading -

Comment - Constellation Brands reveals dire Hardy profits

There are currently no comments on this article

Be the first to comment on this article

Related articles

In the Spotlight - New-Look Constellation Brands

Constellation Brands has reported a mixed start to life as a streamlined wine, beer and spirits operator in North America. Here, just-drinks exmaines the Robert Mondavi winemaker's first quarter-results and looks at the market reaction.

just the Round-Up - The week in drinks

The top ten stories published on just-drinks this week.

US: Constellation Brands toasts Crown Imports for Q1, but sales slide

Constellation Brands has posted a marked fall in net sales in its first fiscal quarter results, but has highlighted the sell-off of its Australian and UK wine business for the decrease.

Read more on this hot issue

Focus - The Current State of Constellation Brands

The release today (6 January) of Constellation Brands' Q3 results means the US drinks giant will hog the headlines at the start of this year as it did at the end of last year. Here's a round-up of Constellation's movements in the last month.

just-drinks tagline

Not a member? Join here

Decrease font sizeDecrease font sizeDecrease font size Increase font sizeIncrease font sizeIncrease font size Comment on this article Email this to a friend Print this page